News

IEC 60044-1 Compliance in Split Core Current Transformers Manufacturing

Split core current transformers (CTs) have become indispensable in modern power monitoring systems, particularly in retrofitting scenarios where non-invasive installation is critical. However, their widespread adoption in safety-critical applications—from solar inverters to industrial grids—demands strict adherence to international standards. IEC 60044-1, titled “Instrument transformers – Part 1: Current transformers,” serves as the foundational standard governing the design, performance, and safety of current transformers, including split core variants. This article explores the key requirements of IEC 60044-1, their implications for split core CT manufacturing, and the processes manufacturers employ to ensure compliance.
1. Overview of IEC 60044-1: Scope and Significance
First published in 1996 and revised most recently in 2018, IEC 60044-1 establishes uniform specifications for current transformers (CTs) used in electrical measurement and protection systems. Its scope encompasses all types of current transformers, regardless of design (solid core, split core, or non-conventional), and applies to both indoor and outdoor applications with rated voltages up to 1,000V (low-voltage) and beyond (high-voltage).
1.1 Core Objectives of the Standard
IEC 60044-1 aims to ensure that CTs:
  • Provide accurate current measurements under specified operating conditions.

  • Withstand electrical stresses, including short circuits and overvoltages.

  • Operate safely without posing fire or electric shock risks.

  • Maintain performance consistency across manufacturing batches and over their service life.

For split core CTs, which differ from solid core designs in their hinged, clamp-around structure, compliance with IEC 60044-1 is particularly challenging due to unique mechanical and electrical constraints. Yet, adherence is non-negotiable for market access in most regions, as regulatory bodies (e.g., EU’s CE marking, U.S. NEC) mandate compliance with IEC or equivalent standards.
2. Key Requirements of IEC 60044-1 for Split Core CTs
IEC 60044-1 outlines hundreds of technical requirements, but several are especially critical for split core CT manufacturers. These requirements address performance, safety, and durability—areas where split core designs face distinct challenges.
2.1 Accuracy Classes and Measurement Performance
IEC 60044-1 defines accuracy classes based on allowable measurement errors at rated current and specified burdens (load impedances). For split core CTs used in monitoring and metering, common accuracy classes include:
  • 0.1 and 0.2: For revenue-grade metering, where errors must not exceed ±0.1% or ±0.2% at rated current.

  • 0.5 and 1.0: For general monitoring, allowing errors up to ±0.5% or ±1.0%.

  • 5P and 10P: For protection applications, where accuracy is defined at 10 to 20 times rated current (to detect faults).

Split core CTs face unique accuracy challenges due to their hinged design, which creates small air gaps in the magnetic circuit. These gaps increase magnetic reluctance, potentially introducing non-linearities and measurement errors. Manufacturers must mitigate this through:
  • Precision Machining: Tight tolerances on core mating surfaces to minimize air gap size (typically <0.1mm).

  • High-Performance Core Materials: Using grain-oriented electrical steel or amorphous alloys with high permeability to reduce reluctance.

  • Calibration: Post-assembly calibration to compensate for residual errors, often using automated systems that adjust winding turns or add correction circuits.

2.2 Thermal Performance and Temperature Rise
CTs generate heat due to copper losses (in windings) and core losses (hysteresis and eddy currents). IEC 60044-1 specifies maximum allowable temperature rises for different insulation classes (e.g., 60K for Class B, 100K for Class F) under continuous rated current.
For split core CTs, thermal management is challenging because:
  • The split design limits heat conduction between core halves.

  • Compact enclosures (required for retrofitting) restrict airflow.

Manufacturers comply by:
  • Low-Loss Design: Using high-conductivity copper for windings to reduce resistive losses.

  • Thermal Simulation: Finite element analysis (FEA) to model heat distribution and optimize enclosure ventilation.

  • Material Selection: Choosing flame-retardant, high-temperature plastics (e.g., PBT or polyamide) for enclosures, rated to withstand temperatures 20-30°C above the standard’s limits.

2.3 Insulation Requirements
IEC 60044-1 mandates insulation systems that prevent dielectric breakdown between live parts (primary and secondary windings) and between live parts and the enclosure (ground). For split core CTs, which often operate in harsh environments (e.g., outdoor solar installations), insulation must resist moisture, UV radiation, and chemical exposure.
Key insulation tests specified by the standard include:
  • Power Frequency Withstand Voltage (PFWV) Test: Applying 2kV (for low-voltage CTs) between windings and ground for 60 seconds without breakdown.

  • Impulse Voltage Test: Subjecting insulation to a 10kV impulse (1.2/50μs wave) to simulate lightning or switching surges.

  • Partial Discharge Test: Ensuring no significant partial discharges (≤10pC) under 1.73 times rated voltage, indicating insulation integrity.

Manufacturers address these requirements by:
  • Encapsulation: Potting windings in epoxy resin or silicone to seal out moisture and prevent corona discharge.

  • Double Insulation: Using two independent insulation layers (e.g., enameled wire plus a plastic barrier) to meet safety factors.

  • Material Certification: Sourcing insulation materials with proven compliance (e.g., UL 94 V0 for flame resistance).

2.4 Short-Circuit Withstand Capability
CTs must survive short-circuit currents—often 20 to 50 times rated current—without mechanical damage or insulation failure. For split core designs, the hinged mechanism is vulnerable to magnetic forces during short circuits, which can pull core halves apart or deform windings.
IEC 60044-1 specifies short-circuit tests where CTs are subjected to peak currents (e.g., 200kA for 1 second) and inspected for:
  • No visible damage to windings or core.

  • Insulation resistance >100MΩ post-test.

  • No degradation in accuracy.

To comply, manufacturers:
  • Reinforce Core Mechanisms: Using robust hinges (e.g., stainless steel) and locking clips to prevent separation under magnetic forces.

  • Overdesign Windings: Increasing conductor cross-sections and using high-temperature insulation to withstand short-circuit heating.

  • Magnetic Shielding: Adding copper or aluminum shields to reduce eddy current losses during faults.

2.5 Mechanical and Environmental Durability
Split core CTs are frequently installed in harsh conditions, so IEC 60044-1 includes tests for mechanical and environmental resilience:
  • Vibration Test: Subjecting CTs to 10-500Hz vibrations (10g acceleration) for 3 hours per axis to simulate transportation or industrial environments.

  • IP Rating Test: Ensuring enclosures meet IP65 (dust-tight, water-resistant) or higher to resist rain, dust, and humidity.

  • UV Exposure Test: For outdoor CTs, 1,000 hours of UV radiation testing to prevent enclosure degradation.

Manufacturers meet these by:
  • Rugged Enclosures: Using impact-resistant plastics (e.g., polycarbonate) with UV stabilizers.

  • Sealed Hinges: Gasketing hinge points to maintain IP ratings while allowing core opening.

  • Corrosion-Resistant Components: Using nickel-plated or stainless-steel hardware to prevent rust.

3. Manufacturing Processes for IEC 60044-1 Compliance
Achieving IEC 60044-1 compliance requires integrating standard-specific controls into every stage of split core CT production, from design to final testing.
3.1 Design and Engineering
  • Computer-Aided Design (CAD): Modeling core geometry to minimize air gaps and optimize magnetic flux distribution, using software like ANSYS Maxwell for electromagnetic simulations.

  • Material Selection: Specifying core materials (e.g., 3% silicon steel for low loss) and insulation (e.g., Class F epoxy) based on IEC 60044-1’s thermal and dielectric requirements.

  • Prototyping and Validation: Building pre-production samples to test for accuracy, thermal rise, and short-circuit withstand capability before mass production.

3.2 Core and Winding Production
  • Core Stamping and Lamination: Precision-stamping core halves from thin (0.23-0.3mm) electrical steel sheets, then annealing to reduce stress and improve permeability.

  • Winding Automation: Using computer numerical control (CNC) winding machines to ensure consistent turns count and uniform tension, critical for accuracy.

  • Assembly Controls: Calibrating hinge alignment during assembly to minimize air gaps, often using laser measurement tools to achieve tolerances <0.05mm.

3.3 Quality Control and Testing
IEC 60044-1 requires 100% testing of key parameters for each CT, plus periodic type tests on representative samples. Inline and offline tests include:
  • Accuracy Testing: Using reference CTs and precision current sources to verify errors at 5%, 100%, and 120% of rated current.

  • Insulation Resistance: Measuring with a 1kV megohmmeter to ensure values >1GΩ.

  • Temperature Rise: Monitoring surface temperatures under rated current using thermocouples, ensuring compliance with insulation class limits.

  • Short-Circuit Simulation: Subjecting samples to fault currents in a test lab to validate mechanical and thermal resilience.

3.4 Documentation and Traceability
IEC 60044-1 mandates comprehensive documentation, including:
  • Type Test Reports: Certifying that a CT model meets all standard requirements, conducted by accredited third-party labs (e.g., UL, VDE).

  • Production Records: Tracking material batches, test results, and calibration data for each unit, enabling traceability in case of failures.

  • User Manuals: Providing installation guidelines (e.g., torque specifications for hinge bolts) to maintain accuracy and safety in field use.

4. Challenges in Compliance for Split Core CTs
While IEC 60044-1 applies to all CTs, split core designs face unique hurdles in meeting its requirements:
4.1 Balancing Accuracy and Design Flexibility
The split core’s hinged structure inherently introduces air gaps, which degrade magnetic performance. Achieving Class 0.2 accuracy requires tight manufacturing tolerances, increasing production costs. Manufacturers often address this by:
  • Using higher-grade core materials (e.g., amorphous steel, 2-3x more expensive than silicon steel) to offset gap-induced losses.

  • Implementing active compensation circuits (e.g., op-amp-based correction) in digital split core CTs to linearize output.

4.2 Ensuring Consistency in Mass Production
Small variations in hinge alignment or winding tension can cause significant accuracy drift between units. To mitigate, manufacturers invest in:
  • Automated assembly lines with robotic hinge alignment.

  • Statistical process control (SPC) to monitor key parameters (e.g., turns count, gap size) and correct deviations in real time.

4.3 Cost vs. Compliance
Third-party type testing (required for certification) is expensive—often exceeding $50,000 per CT model. For small manufacturers, this can be a barrier. Strategies to manage costs include:
  • Partnering with testing consortia to share expenses.

  • Focusing on high-volume, multi-purpose models to spread testing costs across more units.

4.4 Evolving Standards
IEC 60044-1 is periodically revised to address new technologies (e.g., digital CTs) and safety concerns. Manufacturers must stay updated to avoid non-compliance with newer editions. For example, the 2018 revision introduced stricter partial discharge limits for high-voltage CTs, requiring redesigns of insulation systems.
5. Benefits of IEC 60044-1 Compliance
Despite the challenges, compliance with IEC 60044-1 delivers significant advantages for manufacturers, suppliers, and end-users:
5.1 Market Access and Credibility
Compliance is a prerequisite for entering global markets, particularly in the EU (via CE marking), North America (UL/cUL certification), and Asia (IECEx for hazardous areas). It also signals quality to customers, differentiating compliant products in competitive markets.
5.2 Enhanced Reliability and Safety
Compliant split core CTs are less likely to fail in field use, reducing warranty claims and liability risks for manufacturers. For end-users—such as solar farm operators or industrial plants—this translates to fewer outages and lower maintenance costs.
5.3 Interoperability
IEC 60044-1 ensures that split core CTs from different manufacturers perform consistently, enabling seamless integration into monitoring systems. This is critical for large-scale projects (e.g., utility grids) using components from multiple suppliers.
5.4 Future-Proofing
Compliance with current standards positions manufacturers to adapt to emerging regulations, such as stricter efficiency requirements or digital communication protocols (e.g., IEC 61850 for smart grids).
6. Conclusion
IEC 60044-1 compliance is not merely a regulatory obligation but a cornerstone of quality and reliability in split core current transformer manufacturing. For a product category defined by its non-invasive design and versatility, meeting the standard’s rigorous requirements—from accuracy and thermal performance to mechanical durability—demands meticulous engineering, advanced manufacturing processes, and a commitment to quality control.
While split core CTs face unique challenges due to their hinged design, manufacturers that invest in precision machining, high-performance materials, and rigorous testing can achieve compliance without sacrificing functionality. The result is a product that not only accesses global markets but also delivers the reliability and safety required for critical applications in solar energy, industrial automation, and smart grids.
As the demand for retrofittable, high-accuracy monitoring solutions grows, adherence to IEC 60044-1 will remain a key differentiator, ensuring that split core CTs continue to play a vital role in the transition to efficient, sustainable energy systems.


avatar
XUJIA

I graduated from the University of Electronic Science and Technology, majoring in electric power engineering, proficient in high-voltage and low-voltage power transmission and transformation, smart grid and new energy grid-connected technology applications. With twenty years of experience in the electric power industry, I have rich experience in electric power design and construction inspection, and welcome technical discussions.

Share This Article
Whatsapp
Email
Message